Strange Bedfellows? Attitudes toward Religious Minority Symbols in Quebec (Canada)

Title
Strange Bedfellows? Attitudes toward Religious Minority Symbols in Quebec (Canada)
Speaker(s)
Speaker: Luc Turgeon # University of Ottawa
Hosted by
Introduced by
Date and Time
24th Nov 2016 13:00 - 24th Nov 2016 14:30
Location
Project Room, 50 George Square, Edinburgh
URL
http://www.cst.ed.ac.uk/events_at_the_centre/open_research_seminars/2016_2017/strange_bedfellows_attitudes_toward_religious_minority_symbols_in_quebec_canada

This seminar is a joint presentation between Centre for Canadian Studies, CNaM (Citizens, Nation and Migration Network)

There will be a sandwich lunch at 12.30pm prior to the presentation. Please RSVP at this link to let us know if you are coming, so we can plan how much food to order: http://whoozin.com/DEP-DDG-XPRA 

Abstract

Over the last decades, in both Europe and North America, debates have multiplied over the place of minority religious symbols in public spaces. A number of European studies have explored the sources of support for a ban on minority religious symbols. In this study, conducted with Antoine Bilodeau (Concordia University), Ailsa Henderson (University of Edinburgh) and Stephen White (Carleton University), we argue that to understand the sources of such support, it is essential to distinguish those who would ban minority religious symbols from those who would forbid all religious symbols, including those of the majority. While these two groups might share some similar motivations, their opposition to minority religious symbols might also be rooted in different impulses, and as such they might constitute "strange bedfellows". Echoing European debates, we test this argument by drawing on a survey conducted in the province of Quebec in Canada. In 2013, the provincial government proposed a ban on the wearing of religious symbols, including the headscarf, by public employees. While the legislation would have banned the wearing of all religious symbols, public debates focused overwhelmingly on the wearing of headscarves by Muslim women. However, this debate coincided with another one on the removal of the crucifix from the province’s legislative body. As such, the Quebec case allows us to test the potentially distinct motivations of those who would ban only minority religious symbols and those who would ban all religious symbols.